I was hoping John would show up as he was a week ahead of me. I never considered the slide guard and have no complaints with the holster, as ordered.
One thing that does not appear on website photographs which John may be able to handle: Rafter S stitches a channel of parallel raised leather grooves into the interior of the holster; (dimensions 1.5" length, 1/4" height and 3/8" width). This channel guides the R9 sights, for good ingress and egress of the gun from the holster, and it imparts integrity to the fit of the gun while holstered.
Though the R9 rides higher in the Rafter than the 086 DeSantis holster, it is a superior fit. You know the one about the angel and the devil on your shoulder. Lousy customer service, great product.