I extracted the following list of comments from a recent thread, "Oil instead of grease":
1. Eezox, Slide-glide, Miltec, etc., are all great products. Also, Ballistoil, as recommended by Richard is an excellent product.
2. Also GunButter.
3. Wilson's Ultra-Lube Grease.
4. Bruce at Grayguns (custom work) was using Slide-Glide. No crud buildup. Guns are a snap to clean, stuff wipes right off.
5. Maria at Rohrbaugh says they use Hornady One Shot or Miltec for the Slide.
6. +1 on the Slide-Glide (light grade). Brian Enos, the champion shooter / instructor markets this stuff on his website,
http://www.brianenos.com/.
7. Maria (follow-up) says they were no longer recommending the use of grease or lube. She said "use a quality gun oil....the grease tends to pick up and accumulate dirt". She told me that they use Hornady One Shot on all of the parts of the pistol at the factory.
It looks like the factory leans toward One Shot. I have not used it and personally like the feel of Wilson Ultra-Lube. But if grease is no longer recommended (due to dirt attraction)... Surely a good grease has got to protect a slide better than an oil.
How about this: Use a good grease when just shooting at the range and use One-Shot when carrying...
Can we get a consensus on this?
Thanks